Court of Appeal Rules on Bad Faith Claim in Ongoing Logo Dispute
- Tesco wins appeal in court against Lidl trademark dispute
- Court of Appeal in London rules Tesco’s argument should be part of trial
- High Court trial set for next year
Tesco has won an appeal in court that will allow it to argue at trial that Lidl applied for trademarks for a yellow circle against a blue background in ‘bad faith’. This comes after Tesco filed a counterclaim against Lidl last year, following the discount supermarket’s lawsuit claiming Tesco was trying to ‘ride its coat-tails’ by using a similar logo for its Clubcard prices discount scheme. Lidl argues that its blue square containing a yellow circle with a thin red line is a ‘wordless trademark’ and seeks to ban Tesco from using the similar background on its Clubcard prices signs at stores. While a lower court dismissed Tesco’s case on bad faith in June, the Court of Appeal in London ruled that the argument should be part of Lidl’s initial lawsuit and Tesco’s counterclaim, set to be heard at the High Court next year. Both companies remain confident in their positions.
Factuality Level: 8
Factuality Justification: The article provides accurate information about the court case between Tesco and Lidl, with no clear signs of sensationalism or opinion masquerading as fact. It reports on the recent Court of Appeal decision and includes quotes from both companies’ representatives.
Noise Level: 4
Noise Justification: The article provides relevant information about a legal dispute between Tesco and Lidl regarding trademarks but does not offer much analysis or insight beyond reporting on the court’s decision and the companies’ statements.
Financial Relevance: Yes
Financial Markets Impacted: Tesco and Lidl’s legal battle impacts their branding and marketing strategies, which can affect their sales and market share.
Financial Rating Justification: The article discusses a court case between Tesco and Lidl involving trademarks for their logos, which can impact the companies’ branding and marketing strategies. This, in turn, may influence their sales and market share, making it financially relevant.
Presence Of Extreme Event: No
Nature Of Extreme Event: Other
Impact Rating Of The Extreme Event: Minor
Extreme Rating Justification: There is no extreme event mentioned in the text, but it discusses a legal dispute between Tesco and Lidl regarding trademarks.
www.retailsector.co.uk